Comment on "Collective dynamics in liquid lithium, sodium, and aluminum"

Tullio Scopigno, Giancarlo Ruocco

Published 2004-06-04Version 1

In a recent paper, S. Singh and K. Tankeshwar (ST), [Phys. Rev. E \textbf{67}, 012201 (2003)], proposed a new interpretation of the collective dynamics in liquid metals, and, in particular, of the relaxation mechanisms ruling the density fluctuations propagation. At variance with both the predictions of the current literature and the results of recent Inelastic X-ray Scattering (IXS) experiments, ST associate the quasielastic component of the $S(Q,\omega)$ to the thermal relaxation, as it holds in an ordinary adiabatic hydrodynamics valid for non-conductive liquids and in the $Q \to 0$ limit. We show here that this interpretation leads to a non-physical behaviour of different thermodynamic and transport parameters.