A comparison of dust content and properties in GAMA/G10-COSMOS/3D-HST and SIMBA cosmological simulations

Trevor Butrum, Benne Holwerda, Romeel Dave, Kyle Cook, Clayton Robertson, Jochen Liske

Published 2025-05-05Version 1

The abundance of dust within galaxies directly influences their evolution. Contemporary models attempt to match this abundance by simulating the processes of dust creation, growth, and destruction. While these models are accurate, they require refinement, especially at earlier epochs. This study aims to compare simulated and observed datasets and identify discrepancies between the two, providing a basis for future improvements. We utilise simulation data from the SIMBA cosmological simulation suite and observed data from the Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA), a subset of the Cosmic Evolution Survey (G10-COSMOS), and the Hubble Space Telescope (3D-HST). We selected galaxies in the observed and simulated data in a stellar mass range of $(10^{8.59} < M_\odot < 10^{11.5})$ and at redshift bins centering around $(z = 0.0)$, $(z = 0.1)$, $(z = 0.5)$, $(z = 1.0)$, and $(z = 1.5)$ in a homogeneous dust mass range $((10^{6} < M_D [M_\odot] < 10^{9}))$. Our results show notable deviations between SIMBA and observed data for dust-poor and rich galaxies, with strong indications that differences in galaxy populations and SIMBA limitations are the underlying cause rather than the dust physics implemented in SIMBA itself.