Black hole spin measurements in LMC X-1 are highly model-dependent

Andrzej A. Zdziarski, Srimanta Banerjee, Swadesh Chand, Gulab Dewangan, Ranjeev Misra, Michal Szanecki, Andrzej Niedzwiecki

Published 2023-08-11Version 1

The spin parameter of the black hole in the accreting X-ray binary LMC X-1 has been measured in a number of studies to be $a_*\gtrsim 0.9$. These measurements were claimed to take into account both statistical and systematic (model-dependent) uncertainties. We perform new measurements using a recent simultaneous observation of LMC X-1 by NICER and NuSTAR, providing a data set of very high quality. We use the disk continuum method together with improved models for coronal Comptonization. With the standard relativistic blackbody disk model and optically thin Comptonization, we obtain values of $a_*$ similar to those obtained before. We then consider modifications to the standard disk model. Using a phenomenological color correction set to 2, we find lower values of $a_*\approx 0.64$--0.84. We then consider disks thicker than the standard one, i.e., with some dissipation in surface layers, as expected if partially supported by magnetic pressure. To account for that, we assume the disk is covered by a warm and optically thick layer, Comptonizing the emission of the underlying disk. Our model with the lowest $\chi^2$ yields then a low range of the spin, $a_*\approx 0.40^{+0.41}_{-0.32}$. That last model is also in agreement with the inverse disk temperature-luminosity relation found in this source. We conclude that determinations of the spin using the continuum method is highly sensitive to the assumptions about the disk structure.