Hint of a tension between Nuclear physics and Astrophysical observations

Bhaskar Biswas, Prasanta Char, Rana Nandi, Sukanta Bose

Published 2020-08-04Version 1

Observations of neutron stars by the LIGO-Virgo and NICER collaborations have provided us reasonably precise measurements of their various macroscopic properties. In this letter, within a fully Bayesian framework, we combine them to put joint constraints on the properties of neutron stars based on an empirical parameterization of nuclear matter. Within $90 \%$ credible level this parameterization predicts $R_{1.4} = 12.72_{-.65}^{+0.51}$ km and $\Lambda_{1.4} = 624_{-171}^{+180}$ for the radius and dimensionless tidal deformability, respectively, of a $1.4 M_{\odot}$ neutron star. These values imply a somewhat stiffer equation of state for neutron stars in comparison to those found in other studies that were based on spectral or piecewise polytropic parameterization, which are agnostic to nuclear physics constraints. This indicates a tension between nuclear physics inputs and astrophysical observations. Specifically, we show that this empirically parameterized nuclear equation of state disfavors the softness found in astrophysical observations at a statistically significant level.